Categories
Issue 5: Dispersion

From Fire and Dust to Water: Materiality, Temporality and the Transformation of Perception in Digital Media

This essay examines how fire, dust and water mediate human perceptions of time, memory and embodiment, exploring their symbolic and material significance in art and how digital technologies transform sensory experience through simulation, interaction and computational control.

1. Introduction: From Natural Matter to Perceptual Media

Natural elements have cultural meanings that exceed their physical properties. Fire provides the energy necessary for life while also signifying destruction and danger. Dust suggests material deterioration but also records the traces of passing time. Water sustains life while offering a metaphor for movement, change and emotional uncertainty. Such meanings do not exist independently of matter: cultural understandings of the elements emerge through long histories of bodily and practical encounters with their physical characteristics.

Combustion transforms materials in ways that are often irreversible; accumulated dust lends visible form to the passage of time; and flowing water continually challenges stable boundaries. Natural elements can therefore operate not merely as symbols within artworks but as conceptual tools for thinking about temporality, memory, the body and human relationships.

In painting, photography and cinema, natural elements have frequently been presented as visible subjects. Digital technologies, however, also make it possible to simulate, generate and manipulate natural phenomena computationally. Fire can be produced through particle systems; the surfaces and residues of dusty objects can be scanned and reconstructed as three-dimensional data; and water can be rendered through fluid simulation and real-time feedback. These techniques alter both the representation of natural elements and the position of their viewers. What was formerly encountered primarily as an external object can become an experience constituted through bodily movement, algorithms and sensory responses.

The central research question of this essay is: how do the material properties of natural elements inform their symbolic significance in art, and how do digital media reshape human perception and understanding of them? To address this question, the discussion follows three connected areas: fire and the ethics of spectatorship; dust, archives and memory; and water and embodied perception. Each also raises a temporal question: how can combustion, accumulation and flow make otherwise difficult-to-perceive changes visible or imaginable?

2. Fire: Destruction, Visual Attraction and the Ethics of Spectatorship

2.1 The Ambivalent Properties of Fire

Fire is intrinsically ambivalent. On the one hand, it provides light and heat and has been fundamental to survival, technological development and the formation of human civilisations. On the other hand, its destructive capacity can rapidly transform or eliminate the existing forms of materials. This conjunction of creation and destruction has given fire complex symbolic meanings across cultures.

In visual experience, a flame remains in constant motion. Its contours are unstable, and its movements depend on fuel, oxygen and the surrounding environment. Viewers may recognise its movement without being able to anticipate every variation. The flame is thus a distinctive visual object: it attracts attention while also evoking danger.

In The Psychoanalysis of Fire, Gaston Bachelard (1987 [1938]) treats fire as intimately connected to imagination, desire and psychological ambivalence. His interest extends beyond its physical characteristics to the reverie and emotional projections prompted by contemplating flames. This approach suggests that the meanings attached to natural elements emerge not only from their external properties but also from the psychological experiences of viewers. Fire may be understood simultaneously as an external phenomenon and as an object onto which human desires are projected.

2.2 The Moth-to-Flame Motif: Attraction and Self-Destruction

The moth-to-flame motif is a widespread cultural image. A moth may be drawn towards a light source and, in doing so, encounter dangerous heat. In artistic and literary contexts, the phenomenon has often functioned as a metaphor for desire, fixation, self-destruction and apparently irresistible attraction. Crucially, the metaphor does not cast attraction and danger as necessarily opposed forces. Instead, danger may become entangled with the dynamics of attraction.

From the perspective of visual culture, this contradiction can be extended metaphorically to spectatorship in contemporary digital media. People may repeatedly encounter images they know will provoke discomfort or distress. Responses to images of disasters, violence and social crises can encompass compassion, fear, curiosity and visual fascination at the same time. The moth-to-flame motif therefore offers a way of asking why unsettling images continue to command attention. Does looking necessarily constitute understanding? Can repeated visual proximity coincide with emotional desensitisation? This analogy concerns a symbolic relationship between attraction and potential harm; it does not imply that moth behaviour and human media consumption share the same psychological cause.

2.3 Disaster Imagery and the Ethics of Digital Spectatorship

In Regarding the Pain of Others, Susan Sontag (2003) examines the ethical questions raised by photographic representations of war, violence and suffering. She questions whether images can automatically produce understanding, compassion or political action. To witness another person’s suffering through an image does not necessarily mean understanding the social and historical circumstances in which it occurs.

These questions become more complex on contemporary digital platforms, where disaster imagery appears alongside everyday life, entertainment and commercial content within continuous feeds. Different forms of imagery occupy similar interface structures and circulate through platform-specific mechanisms. As a result, viewers may encounter disturbing events repeatedly without sufficient time or context to understand them. Infinite scrolling generates a particular temporal rhythm: before one image has been fully considered, another has already appeared.

Under these conditions, attention to an event risks becoming consumption of a continual sequence of visual stimuli. Fire acquires a double significance in this context. It may represent disaster itself while also symbolising the entanglement of attraction and danger in digitally mediated spectatorship. Research into fire consequently extends beyond the visual depiction of a natural phenomenon towards the ethical relationship between viewer, image and media system.

3. Dust: Material Traces, Archival Power and the Incompleteness of Memory

3.1 Dust as a Material Form of Time

Unlike the immediate transformations of a flame, dust often makes time perceptible through gradual accumulation. Composed of fine particles from varied sources, including minerals, fibres and other material fragments, dust settles on surfaces and is redistributed by moving air and environmental changes. Its presence can therefore disclose temporal processes that are otherwise difficult to observe. An untouched object may slowly become coated in dust, its altered surface suggesting an extended period of absence. Dust can signify not only deterioration but also time, forgetting and what remains.

In Dust: The Archive and Cultural History, Carolyn Steedman (2001) connects dust with historical research and archival practice. Her work emphasises that historical knowledge is not the straightforward recovery of an intact past; rather, it is produced through surviving documents, material traces and their interpretation. Dust thus has a double meaning: it may be treated as a contaminant that obstructs preservation, yet it also draws attention to the material and historical conditions of the archive. The archive is not a neutral container exempt from time; its own materials remain subject to change.

3.2 The Selectivity and Power of the Archive

Jacques Derrida’s Archive Fever (1996) examines relationships among archival practices, institutional authority, memory and control. The formation of an archive entails more than preservation: it also involves decisions about what is considered worthy of preservation. As records are collected, categorised and retained, others are excluded, overlooked or lost. An archive is consequently not a complete copy of the past but a constructed presentation shaped by selective processes (Derrida, 1996).

3.3 Dust in Modern and Contemporary Art

As a material and visual subject in art, dust challenges aspirations towards completeness, cleanliness and permanence. Man Ray’s photograph Dust Breeding (1920), made in relation to Marcel Duchamp’s The Large Glass, is a particularly significant example. The photograph records dust that had accumulated on the glass surface. Here dust ceases to be merely an impurity requiring removal and becomes matter capable of being observed, recorded and reinterpreted as an image.

Photography converts an accumulation that might otherwise remain unnoticed into a visual object in its own right. This transformation also makes the relationship between photography and time apparent. Accumulation occurs over a duration, whereas the photograph fixes one state of that continuing process. Dust Breeding can thus be interpreted as a double record of time: dust registers ongoing material changes, while photography records a particular configuration of those changes. This distinction offers a useful precedent for examining digital scanning and archival reconstruction. Both photography and three-dimensional capture can translate material traces into images, but that translation necessarily excludes aspects of the original material experience.

3.4 Dust, Geological Temporality and Digital Media Materiality

In Chapter 4 of A Geology of Media, Jussi Parikka (2015) examines dust as a material phenomenon connecting geological temporality, technological production, human labour and environmental transformation. Rather than treating dust simply as a passive residue, he draws attention to its accumulation, circulation and participation in continuing physical processes. His account extends dust beyond conventional associations with decay, disappearance and memory: it becomes a way of investigating the infrastructures that sustain digital culture, including mineral extraction, industrial manufacturing and electronic waste.

Parikka (2015) also challenges the apparent immateriality of digital media. Although digital technologies are often experienced through clean interfaces and seemingly weightless information, their production requires physical resources, energy and labour. Dust can consequently make perceptible environmental and bodily consequences that remain largely invisible to consumers. Where Steedman (2001) considers dust in relation to historical knowledge and the material archive, Parikka situates it within wider technological and ecological processes. Read together, these perspectives suggest that dust records not only what has passed away but also the material systems through which contemporary culture continues to be produced.

3.5 The Paradox of Digital Preservation and Disappearance

Digital technologies are frequently associated with replication, preservation and long-term storage. Yet information remains dependent on hardware, file formats, access permissions and technological change. Digitisation therefore cannot guarantee permanent survival. More importantly, digital reconstruction may create a misleading impression of completeness. A three-dimensional model can display an apparently continuous and coherent surface, encouraging viewers to assume that an object has been entirely restored. Visual completeness, however, is not equivalent to historical completeness.

From this perspective, dust offers a critical approach to preservation. It reminds us that material histories contain absences, dispersals and losses that cannot be fully recovered. Dust signifies not simply forgetting but also the limitations of the attempt to preserve. Its material instability challenges the assumption that a technologically accurate representation can fully reproduce the history of an object.

4. Water: Fluidity, Embodied Perception and Liquid Intimacy

4.1 The Fluidity of Water and Emotional Metaphor

Water flows, disperses, gathers and changes form. Unlike a solid with relatively stable boundaries, the shape it takes is conditioned by containers, gravity, temperature and its surroundings. Fluidity has therefore made water a recurring symbol of change, life, emotion and uncertainty. In visual art, water may convey calmness and continuity as readily as danger, loss of control and bodily vulnerability. Its significance remains open: the same body of water may be understood as a source of life or as a force capable of engulfing a body. Such ambivalence makes water useful for considering emotional relationships.

4.2 Bauman, Liquid Modernity and Intimate Relationships

In Liquid Love: On the Frailty of Human Bonds, Zygmunt Bauman (2003) uses liquidity as a metaphor for instability within contemporary interpersonal relationships. Individuals may desire connection while also feeling anxious about enduring commitment and dependence. Relationships can consequently remain suspended between attachment and separation, freedom and reliance. Liquidity describes not merely the possibility of rupture but the absence of an assured and permanent form.

For artistic research, this raises the question of whether constantly changing materials and images can evoke the instability of intimacy. The movement of water may function as a visual metaphor for this condition, but fluid movement cannot be equated with actual relationships. Emotional bonds involve memory, personal experience, social structures and subjective intention; their complexity cannot be reduced to physical simulation. Liquidity is therefore more productive as a critical concept than as a complete explanation of intimacy.

4.3 Water, the Body and Phenomenology

Maurice Merleau-Ponty’s Phenomenology of Perception foregrounds the body not merely as something observed but as the basis of perceptual experience (Merleau-Ponty, 2012). This account is particularly relevant to human encounters with water. Bodily experience in water differs from that on land: buoyancy, resistance, pressure and altered forms of movement change how a person senses both themselves and their environment.

Swimming requires continual adjustment of bodily orientation and balance; floating entails a degree of dependence on the supporting force of water; sinking may destabilise one’s control over position and direction. These experiences make water a medium through which vulnerability, dependence and environmental perception can be explored. Water is not simply an external setting but participates, through embodied experience, in how the subject understands their own body.

4.4 Bill Viola: Water and the Transformation of the Body

The moving-image art of Bill Viola offers significant examples of relations between water and embodied experience. In The Reflecting Pool (1977–79), Viola uses a human figure, a pool and manipulated video time to explore the instability of bodily presence, disappearance and perception. The treatment of time unsettles familiar expectations about bodily movement. The surface of the pool functions as a distinctive visual interface through which the relationships among body, reflection and temporality are altered.

In Surrender (2001), Viola uses reflections in water and bodily movement to explore transformations of emotion and the human image. Disturbances of the water disrupt the apparent integrity of the figure. The visible body therefore ceases to appear stable; distortions, delays and repetitions keep it in a state of transformation. Viola’s work demonstrates how moving images can manipulate duration and perception to lend water psychological and emotional significance.

4.5 From the Temporality of Two-Dimensional Images to Real-Time Audiovisual Interaction

The representation of water in art long predates digital technology. David Hockney’s A Bigger Splash (1967) fixes a fleeting splash in a two-dimensional painting. Although the water suggests that an action has just occurred, the image withholds the person responsible for it. Through that absence, viewers imagine an event that is not directly depicted. The splash becomes both an image and an indirect trace of time and action.

Where Hockney arrests movement in a still composition, Viola reorganises the temporal relations between water and bodies through moving image. Contemporary computational art develops a further possibility through real-time visual generation and sensing technologies. Images need no longer unfold according to an entirely fixed sequence; they can change in response to environmental data or visitors’ bodily behaviour.

In Interactive Art and Embodiment, Nathaniel Stern (2013) emphasises the significance of bodily participation in interactive art. His work encourages a question: if movement can affect an image, does looking become a form of participation? Such participation, however, remains bounded by a programmed system. Sensors can register distance, movement and other measurable parameters, but they do not directly measure emotion or subjective experience. Real-time responsiveness does not mean that technology understands its audience. Instead, interactive artworks construct designed relations between bodily behaviour and digital feedback. This produces an important tension: technical responsiveness may intensify participation without ensuring emotional reciprocity.

5. Comparative Discussion: Elemental Temporality and Digital Transformation

5.1 Three Elements and Three Experiences of Time

Comparison of fire, dust and water reveals different temporal structures. Fire foregrounds events, consumption and irreversible transformation. Dust suggests accumulation, material decay and historical residue. Water evokes continuous movement, cycles and unstable forms. These experiences are not isolated: burning may generate particulate residues; water can transport and deposit dust; and water itself changes state through evaporation and condensation. Such transformations suggest that matter does not exist in permanently fixed forms but remains subject to change.

From the perspective of art research, the elements provide ways of thinking with time. They allow processes that would otherwise remain invisible or difficult to grasp to become perceptible, imaginable or materially registered. The tripartite comparison proposed here is an analytical framework for this essay rather than a claim that every instance of fire, dust or water must conform to one temporal meaning.

5.2 From Material Traces to Digital Data

Photography, scanning, three-dimensional reconstruction and computational simulation permit natural elements to enter digital media in different forms. Yet digitisation does not transfer a natural phenomenon intact into another space; it is a process of translation. The motion of flames may become particle parameters; surface traces of dust may become images or three-dimensional data; and flows of water may be generated through algorithms and physical simulation.

These translations introduce new possibilities for manipulation. Artists can adjust speed, scale, colour, form and responsiveness. At the same time, computational systems abstract the phenomena they represent: complex material events become parameters that can be calculated and controlled. Digital media thus expand the expressive potential of natural elements while sometimes distancing them from their original material and environmental conditions. Parikka’s (2015) account of media materiality also reminds us that the digital systems enabling these translations remain dependent upon physical matter.

5.3 From Spectatorship to Bodily Participation

Representations of nature have commonly positioned viewers as observers of an external world. In interactive art, however, the viewer’s body may become part of the conditions through which the work operates. By moving, approaching or withdrawing, participants can affect the generation of images and sound rather than simply encountering an already completed sequence.

Nevertheless, participation is always organised through design decisions. The changes viewers can trigger depend on the mappings established between incoming data and the system’s outputs. Consequently, the significance of interactive art does not lie simply in making images change but in revealing how relations among bodies, technology and perception are constructed (Stern, 2013).

5.4 The Distance Between Technical Representation and Lived Experience

Research into fire, dust and water ultimately raises a common question: to what extent can digital technology reproduce lived experience? Images of disaster do not automatically communicate the ethical complexity of the events they depict (Sontag, 2003). A digital archive cannot retain the complete history and material existence of an object (Derrida, 1996). Real-time interaction does not provide direct access to a participant’s emotional state.

These limitations do not diminish the artistic significance of digital media. Rather, they offer a starting point for critical inquiry. By exposing the gaps between data and experience, representation and reality, or response and understanding, computational art can encourage viewers to consider how technology shapes knowledge of the world.

6. Conclusion

This essay has examined how the material properties of fire, dust and water inform their symbolic significance in art and how digital mediation changes perceptions of nature, temporality, memory and the body. The discussion of fire identified the tension between visual fascination and danger, extending it to disaster imagery and spectatorship in digital culture. The analysis of dust showed that material traces not only register time but also illuminate the selection, omissions and uncertainties of archival preservation and historical reconstruction. The discussion of water used fluidity and embodied experience to consider the instability of human relationships and the capacities and limitations of interactive technologies to translate bodily action into sensory feedback.

Together, these perspectives suggest that natural elements are more than visual material for art. Their physical characteristics provide different frameworks through which abstract aspects of human experience can be examined. Digital technologies, meanwhile, are not transparent instruments of representation. Through selection, abstraction, simulation and programmed control, they reorganise relations between natural phenomena and their audiences.

What matters most for research at the intersection of natural elements and computational art, therefore, is not whether technology can produce sufficiently realistic images of nature, but how it changes the ways natural phenomena are perceived, interpreted and experienced. This framework also informs my future artistic practice in moving image, digital archives, virtual bodies and real-time interaction. Digitising natural elements does not reproduce natural experience in its entirety; it constructs new relations of perception.

references

Bachelard, G. (1987) The Psychoanalysis of Fire. Translated by A.C.M. Ross. Boston: Beacon Press. (Originally published in 1938).

Bauman, Z. (2003) Liquid Love: On the Frailty of Human Bonds. Cambridge: Polity Press.

Derrida, J. (1996) Archive Fever: A Freudian Impression. Translated by E. Prenowitz. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

Merleau-Ponty, M. (2012) Phenomenology of Perception. Translated by D.A. Landes. London: Routledge.

Parikka, J. (2015) A Geology of Media. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

Sontag, S. (2003) Regarding the Pain of Others. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

Steedman, C. (2001) Dust: The Archive and Cultural History. Manchester: Manchester University Press.

Stern, N. (2013) Interactive Art and Embodiment: The Implicit Body as Performance. Canterbury: Gylphi.

about the author

Di’ou Guo is a London-based interdisciplinary artist and researcher pursuing an MA in Fine Art: Computational Arts at the University of the Arts London. She holds a BA in Digital Media Art from the Central Academy of Fine Arts, China. Her practice explores the relationships between natural elements, human perception and digital mediation through moving images, immersive installations and interactive technologies. Her research focuses on how computational media reshape experiences of materiality, memory and embodiment, bridging artistic practice with critical and theoretical inquiry.