This essay explores how artistic practice can encourage people to critically examine and reflect on the attention economy. Beginning with the investigation of incidents such as telecommunications fraud and the privacy risks associated with users’ personal data, I then draw on Herbert Simon’s argument in 1971 that an abundance of information creates a scarcity of attention (1971, p.40). This led me to question how users’ information can be extracted by digital platforms. Rather than being mere users, are they also becoming the products themselves? When people continuously leave traces of their behaviour on digital platforms, are they truly aware of how this data is collected, analyzed and exploited by digital systems?
Under the architecture of the Internet, digital platforms achieve information exchange, content sharing, etc. by connecting users. In the early 2000s, social media was defined as a platform through which people could use digital technologies to engage in social interactions with friends and others (boyd, 2026). However, the nature of social media has since evolved, especially with social media and the rapidly developing generative artificial intelligence, which enables people to access and disseminate vast amounts of information more quickly and extensively. Nevertheless, this rapid circulation of information and the overwhelming volume of content entering everyday life have also raised concerns. For instance, harmful content spreads more widely and appears in various forms such as text, images, videos and audio, threatening public safety. Although technology has been strengthened, at the same time, technology itself may also be abused, exacerbating existing social problems (Oboler, Liu and Jamil, 2024). In addition to the social impact brought about by information dissemination, digital platforms are also gradually changing the relationship between people and information. With the frequent occurrence of online incidents, attracting and maintaining users’ attention has also become an a crucial aspect of the operation of contemporary digital platforms.
During the course of my research, I found that attention has become one of the most valuable resources in the digital age. Long before the widespread adoption of the internet, Simon (1971) pointed out that the abundance of information would lead to the poverty of attention. After the mid-1990s, scholars such as Goldhaber adopted this economic perspective and used the term “attention economy” to describe attention as a scarce resource that can be analyzed and traded (Goldhaber, 1997, cited in ‘Attention economy’, 2026, para.9). In economic theory, the unexpected consequences of market exchange are known as negative externalities. The attention economy generates negative externalities for society, affecting individuals and communities. For example, social media addiction and mental health effects, the amplification of disinformation and surveillance capitalism and ethical considerations (‘Attention economy’, 2026). Carpentier (2023) argued that under current market conditions, platforms compete to capture users’ attention at the lowest possible cost and keep them engaged for as long as possible. To maximize engagement, algorithms may prioritize sensational, controversial, or polarizing content, increasing audiences’ exposure to harmful information and potentially undermining their ability to make informed decisions.
Among them, Zuboff (2015, p.83) pointed out that the reason why these monitoring capitalist platforms can accelerate the speed of law and regulation is that the speed at which they make profits far exceeds the speed at which the public understands. They quietly occupy people’s daily lives, while the public often lacks sufficient awareness of how their data is collected and used, or how digital systems extract information from their daily online activities. Clicking buttons, checking phones, and scrolling through feeds have become habitual parts of everyday life rather than deliberate actions. This gradually led me to question whether, when platforms predict users’ interests based on their past behaviour and continuously recommend similar content, these recommendations are simply satisfying existing needs or also shaping users’ future preferences and choices. However, I do not believe that digital technology necessarily deprives users of their autonomy. Digital platforms also provide opportunities for accessing information, communicating, and expressing oneself. Therefore, my concern is not how people can completely escape digital technology, but how they can develop a clearer understanding of the relationship between their own behaviour and digital systems, while maintaining critical awareness in their use of technology.
Subsequently, when reading “Networks” (2014) edited by Lars Bang Larsen, I came across Tiziana Terranova’s Network Dynamics, which describes networks as dynamic systems characterized by constant change, flows and complex relationships. This further reinforced my understanding that our behaviors on digital platforms do not exist in isolation. Every click, pause and interaction may contribute to a broader flow of information. However, when these behaviors are recorded, analyzed and predicted by the digital platforms, the originally complex and diverse human behaviors may be transformed into calculable data patterns. Narayanan (2023) also points out that content on digital platforms is largely shaped by recommendation algorithms. For example, recommendation algorithms serve as core mechanisms on platforms such as Facebook and YouTube, TikTok, furthermore, operates an almost entirely algorithm-driven model of content distribution.
Nicky Case ‘s browser-based game We Become What We Behold (Case, 2016) inspired my artwork. It is a simple interactive game in which players use a camera viewfinder as their cursor to capture events and behaviors. The game demonstrates how repeated exposure to information can reinforce imitation and homogenization of behaviour. Despite its simple visual style, the game conveys profound philosophical ideas.
It also provides an interesting comparison with my research on the attention economy. In the game, individuals initially display different behaviors, but gradually begin to imitate one another and become increasingly similar. At the same time, the digital platform continuously extracts and amplifies certain characteristics of the crowd. For example, when the player photographs a character wearing a hat, the hat becomes a focal point of attention, and other characters gradually begin wearing hats as well (Fig.1). However, when negative emotions emerge within the crowd, such as a square character expressing hostility towards a circle character (Fig. 2), the conflict is repeatedly amplified and eventually escalates beyond control. This made me realize that players are not merely observers of information but also active participants in its production. As the system continues to circulate and amplify particular content, users’ choices and behaviors may also change in response.

Fig.1. Screenshots from We Become What We Behold (Case, accessed 2026)

Fig.2. Screenshots from We Become What We Behold (Case, accessed 2026)
Nicky’s artwork make me realize that criticism of the attention economy in words often remains at the descriptive level, whereas interactive art can break down the boundaries between audiences and traditional media. The audience is no longer merely passive recipients of information, but actively participate in the development of artworks through their own choices, actions, and feedback. Interactive artworks often possess nonlinear and open-ended characteristics. where different choices may lead to different outcomes, making each experience somewhat unique. Interactive art can immerse audiences within a system, allowing them to contribute to the creation of the artwork through their interactions. This participatory process can create a sense of immersion and provide opportunities to recreate the underlying mechanisms of the attention economy within an interactive environment. Through game-based experiences, these mechanisms can be communicated in a more intuitive and engaging way.
Digital platforms include various types, such as social media platforms, search platforms, e-commerce platforms, gaming platforms. Among them, social media is currently one of the most popular platforms. It is estimated that as of October 2025, the number of global social media user identities will be approximately 5.66 billion, accounting for 68.7% of the global population (Kemp, 2025). Therefore, in my artwork practice, I choose to take the social media platform as the object and transform it into a game environment that can interact with the audience, guiding the audience to conduct more in-depth reflection in a relaxed atmosphere. And it adopted three popular themes in social media recently: pets, news and food to attract users’ attention as information elements.
During the development of my game’s content, Hito Steyerl’s Digital Debris: Spam and Scam not only helped me understand the phenomenon of information overload in the digital age, but also inspired me to further explore the changing relationships between users, information and commodities through interactive art. Steyerl (2011, p.110) describes spam as a form of “debris” in the digital age, “a widespread phenomenon in the digital environment, reflecting an era in which excess has become a fundamental principle.” When discussing the operational logic of commercial spam, she argues that “By disseminating information on a large scale and repeatedly, commercial benefits can be generated even if only a very small number of people respond” (p.112).
In my own practice (Fig.3), I have incorporated a similar logic of information overload into the design of the game’s interface. Through a continuous flow of information and repetitive recommendation mechanisms, I aim to simulate how digital platforms compete for users’ attention. When audiences select their preferences for the first time, the system begins recording their choices and subsequently provides repeated personalized recommendations. As the number of clicks increases, similar content progressively occupies more of the screen, and once the system has finished collecting information, the game moves on to the next mechanism.

Fig.3. Screenshots from Data Commodity (Yang, 2026)
While researching how users are transformed into commodities, I came across Hito Steyerl’s Mission Accomplished: Belanciege (2019), which encouraged me to reconsider the relationship between user participation and commercial value on digital platforms. The artwork is presented as a three-channel high-definition video installation in the form of a staged lecture performance (Steyerl, 2019). It demonstrates the ways of making, uploading and sharing products on social media. One of the core arguments is that the product pictures shared through social media turn users into unpaid workers (Fig.4). This point is directly related to my own artistic practice. Every choice made by players is actually generating data for the platform for free. With these data, the digital platform can operate rapidly, and these data themselves are commodities.

Fig.4. Hito Steyerl, Giorgi Gago Gagoshidze and Miloš Trakilović, Mission Accomplished: Belanciege (2019), video still. Source: Hito Steyerl’s official website.
Trevor Paglen and Kate Crawford’s ImageNet Roulette (2019) further shaped my understanding of data labels in digital systems. Based on the “person” categories of ImageNet, the project allows participants to upload photographs and receive machine-generated classification labels, revealing how artificial intelligence reduces complex human identities to pre-defined categories. This led me to reflect on how digital platforms classify users through their everyday online behaviour. Although ImageNet Roulette focuses mainly on image classification, I began to consider how similar classification processes might be applied to behavioral data, such as clicks, watch time and content preferences. These behaviors may be converted into data labels, which platforms use to build user profiles and to inform personalized recommendations. However, I also began to question whether these labels truly represent users’ interests and identities, or merely reflect the assumptions of the systems that generate them. This line of thinking informed the design of my work. In it, I simulate real market labels: the user profile gathered through data collection serves as a distinctive symbol on each label; the valuable information sold is priced, and the resulting monetary value is printed out. Each different data value also corresponds to a different type of commodity.
During the degree show in July 2026, I used my interactive game as a medium for communication and discussion with the audience. I invited visitors to experience the artwork firsthand and explore the game, allowing them to engage with how digital platforms collect behavioral data and influence users’ choices through system feedback. At the same time, I actively engaged in face-to-face conversations with visitors, introducing the research background and creative intentions behind the work, and inviting them to share their feelings during the game as well as their perspectives on everyday digital platform use.
As a result, I received a range of feedback from the audience, alongside discussions during tutorials and group critiques, which played an important role in reshaping my understanding of the research direction. During the exhibition, different audience expressed different opinions. Some believed that the positive effects of these technological mechanisms outweighed their negative impacts. One audience argued that personalized recommendations and data analysis could reduce the time spent searching for information and make everyday life more convenient. She even felt that she had become entirely dependent on the convenience brought by technology (Fig. 5). These different perspectives encouraged me to reflect on my initial assumptions: Had I focused too much on the negative impacts of technology while overlooking people’s actual needs and the benefits they experience?

Fig.5. Photograph by the author (2026)
After reading A New Digital Deal: How the Digital World Could Work (2021), I gained a new perspective on this issue. In particular, Lukas’s(2021, p.23) discussion of “Technology for the People and by the People” resonated with me. This idea encouraged me to reconsider the relationship between technological development and human needs. Technology should not only serve people, but also allow them to participate in its design, development and decision-making processes, rather than simply accepting the outcomes of technological advancement. This gradually made me realize that technology itself is neither entirely good nor bad. Personalized recommendations may help people access information more efficiently, but they may also influence their choices by continuously capturing their attention and analyzing their behavioral data.
Therefore, I believe that what truly deserves our attention is not simply the negative impact of these technologies, but rather what kind of relationship we want to establish with them, and how we can preserve people’s autonomy, right to information and right to participation while enjoying the convenience they offer. The attention economy is everywhere, and everyone spends their attention every day. Making the attention economy sustainable requires collective responsibility and participation.
Through my artistic practice, I hope to raise awareness of the relationship between human autonomy and digital technology. Rather than being overly concerned with whether technology stands in opposition to or will replace us, we should explore how technology can not only serve people but also be shaped by them.
Images
Case, N. (2016) We become what we behold [Browser game]. Available at: https://ncase.me/attention/ (Accessed: 9 November 2026).
Yang, L. (2026) Data Commodity [Browser game].
Steyerl, H. (2019) Mission Accomplished: Belanciege. Available at: https://www.hitosteyerl.net/ (Accessed: 9 November 2026).
Reference
‘Attention Economy’ (2026) Wikipedia. Available at: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attention_economy (Accessed: 30 October 2026).
boyd, d. (2026) ‘Social Media Is Now Parasocial Media’. Social Media + Society, 12(2). Available at: https://doi.org/10.1177/20563051261437487
Carpentier, C.L. (2023) New economics for sustainable development: attention economy. United Nations Economist Network. Available at: https://www.un.org/sites/un2.un.org/files/attention_economy_feb.pdf(Accessed: 30 October 2026).
Case, N. (2016) We Become What We Behold [Browser game]. Available at: https://ncase.itch.io/wbwwb (Accessed: 30 October 2026).
Kemp, S. (2025) Digital 2026: global overview report. DataReportal. Available at: https://datareportal.com/reports/digital-2026-global-overview-report (Accessed: 1 November 2026).
Larsen, L.B. (ed.) (2014) Networks. London: Whitechapel Gallery; Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Lukas, M. (2021) ‘A New Digital Deal: Technology for the People and by the People’, in Jandl, M. and Stocker, G. (eds.) A New Digital Deal: How the Digital World Could Work. Berlin: Hatje Cantz, p. 23.
Narayanan, A. (2023) Understanding social media recommendation algorithms. New York: Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University. Available at: https://knightcolumbia.org/content/understanding-social-media-recommendation-algorithms (Accessed: 1 November 2026).
Oboler, A., Liu, Y. and Jamil, N. (2024) ’Message from the General and Program Chairs’, 2024 IEEE Digital Platforms and Societal Harms (DPSH). 14-15 October. IEEE, pp.i-iii. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1109/DPSH60098.2024.10774734 (Accessed:29 October 2026).
Paglen, T. and Crawford, K. (2019) ImageNet Roulette [Interactive artwork]. Available at: https://paglen.studio/2020/04/29/imagenet-roulette/ (Accessed: 2 November 2026).
Steyerl, H. (2011) ‘Digital Debris: Spam and Scam’, October, (138), pp. 70–80. Available at: https://research.ebsco.com/plink/2c25dba5-aa3c-3c6a-b7ac-4ed43ed45bc0 (Accessed: 1 November 2026).
Steyerl, H. (2019) Mission Accomplished: Belanciege. Available at: https://www.hitosteyerl.net/works/mission-accomplished-belanciege/ (Accessed: 1 November 2026).
Simon, H.A. (1971) ’Designing organizations for an information-rich world’, in Greenberger, M. (ed.) Computers, communications, and the public interest. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins Press, pp. 37-72.
Zuboff, S. (2015) ’Big other: surveillance capitalism and the prospects of an information civilization’, Journal of Information Technology, 30(1), pp. 75-89. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1057/jit.2015.5
About the author
Luwei Yang is an interdisciplinary artist whose practice focuses on Human-Computer Interaction (HCI), exploring the relationship between humans and computational systems and how this relationship can be expressed artistically within contemporary technological contexts. She graduated from Camberwell College of Arts, MA Fine Art: Computational Arts in 2026.
Instagram: luvluwei