Introduction
I will begin by discussing how we can perceive human identity in this world through the perspectives of Jane Bennett, Donna Haraway, and Zhuangzi. Following this, I will examine various methods of depicting the body in painting and their corresponding significances, ranging from the “Body as an Organ” to the “Body without Organs,” and finally to William Blake’s concept of the “Body as Imagination.” I will then discuss the potential fusion of these approaches and explore the “metamorphosing body” by combining these theories with my own practice and understanding.
Furthermore, I will discuss two approaches involving spontaneous drawing: Marion Milner’s “Free Drawing” and Jane Bennett’s “Doodling.” By contrasting these with rational, controlled methods of drawing, and drawing on my own creative process, I will explore the painter’s role in image-making. I will also employ a psychoanalytic perspective to examine how painters can recognize their subconscious through the act of drawing. Finally, I will conclude by summarizing the reflexivity of figurative drawing and painting through my own work, discussing how it aids in reacquainting the self.
My understanding of human identity in this era
Without a doubt, we now live in a world that requires vigilance: natural disasters are increasing, hate speech is constantly being incited, AI development is out of control, and the economy is becoming increasingly difficult to operate. It seems hard for us to believe any longer in the idea that humans can transform nature, repair these problems through their agency, and solve difficulties through reason—as if humans were no longer the acting subject completely separated from all other animals, but rather an agent moving toward a disaster-filled future continuously driven by its own excessive behavior. In the face of these disasters, humans appear so weak that we have to reconsider so-called authoritative science and scientific knowledge. If people no longer humbly accept feelings of humility, no longer hold awe toward this world, but instead firmly believe that what they do is absolutely correct, the world will eventually punish us.
How do people living in the present perceive their identity? How do they imagine the shape of their existence as human beings, and what kind of individual they are? From Whitehead’s perspective, there is no absolute substantial human being, only an assemblage of events within a process of flux. From a Daoist perspective, humans can constantly change and have no absolutely fixed categories; or rather, humans and things can transform into one another and are not absolutely different. If we look at traditional naturalism painting, when speaking of people we must think only of anatomically standard human proportions and correctly modeled standard human faces. A figure represents an identity, the subject in an event, and the fact that he can achieve a result through certain actions; and then whether this result and this event are completed by this person or jointly caused by other factors behind the reasoning of the world, including the subject’s actions, etc. In other words, when so-called naturalism depicts a figure with certain characteristics and identity, can the result seen by the eye alone fail to express such an existence jointly influenced by contemporary complex relations and environmental things? And how much of this seemingly stable image and classification of identity is constructed by social, linguistic, and power structures, to the point of bringing oppression? Because of the development of online games, people can now even regard themselves as a fictional character, or as a carefully packaged social persona.
“actual occasion exhibits itself as a process: it is a becomingness.”
Whitehead, Science and the Modern World.
From this we can look again at portrait painting. Amid so many extremely unstable and dispersed images and identity identifications, how do we grasp a person’s image and existence? Daoism says that there are countless laws constituting this world, but ultimately there is one “Dao” hidden behind the patterns of things. Dao is a fundamental, undamageable law of change—not a state of change, but the operating manner of change itself. Zhuangzi gave an example: Kun and Peng. Kun is a huge fish, but after it grows even larger, the local sea can no longer contain it, so it grows wings, flies into the sky, and becomes a giant bird. Things are not fixed, nor must they act according to the categories and norms people assign to them. If we leap beyond the human scale, things are always changing and have no fixed classification. Setting aside all traditional scientific definitions and delimitations of the human, with the continuous development of AI technology, biotechnology, aerospace technology, and so on, the boundaries of the human will be constantly shattered. Humans will not act only by relying on a self-sufficient body and brain, but will merge with various tools, with various drugs invented by humans, and with technological devices—just as Haraway mentions in “A Cyborg Manifesto”: contemporary human identity can no longer return to the former naturalistic image, such as the male and female gods returning to pastoral life. On the contrary, a monstrous hybrid identity—chimerical or cyborg-style—is what is real. If we now create an image without grasping these characteristics, without grasping the tension between humans and these technologies, and between humans and social discourse, but merely use the techniques of naturalistic realism (concrete human form, standard structure, rational painting process), then such portrait painting is far from enough. As Bacon said, “…a painter should understand realism more innovatively; we need to reinvent realism.”
“High-tech culture challenges these dualisms in intriguing ways.
It is not clear who makes and who is made in the relation between human and machine.
It is not clear what is mind and what body in machines that resolve into coding practices.
In so far as we know ourselves in both formal discourse (for example, biology) and in daily practice (for example, the homework economy in the integrated circuit), we find ourselves to be cyborgs, hybrids, mosaics, chimeras.”
Donna Harawy, A Cyborg Manifesto – Science, Technology, and Socialist-Feminism in the Late Twentieth Century
When creating a portrait painting today, how should we consider the meaning of images to us? We use images: emojis, for example, avatars, photos that can be placed on one’s social platforms, virtual images used in games and social software, and so on. It is not that the image represents a concrete view of personhood, but rather that a person has formed some connection with this image, developed some preference or fondness for it, and therefore uses this image as an avatar of themselves. In Zhuangzi’s “Discussion on Making All Things Equal,” there is a story: he dreamed that he became a butterfly, and he felt that being a butterfly was so joyful that after he woke up he wondered whether he had dreamed of being a butterfly or had originally been a butterfly, and whether the butterfly was dreaming of becoming a human. If we feel that a cat or a dog better fits an image in our heart, or a butterfly, why should we still cling to the human appearance, or the inner image of the human, or the image a person prefers and hopes to present? The image in which I feel comfortable is often different from my real appearance; and is such an avatar not something like an identity? The virtual may sometimes be more real.
“Heaven and Earth were born together with me, and all things and I are one.”
James Legge, The Writings of Chuang Tzu.
The meaning of a human body
What does a human body mean to a person? It is a person’s appearance, a person’s bodily form. Rather than caring about whether the proportions are harmonious, whether the figure is good enough, whether it is fat or thin, or whether it matches this person’s real appearance, I care more about the human body as an image, possessing its own volume and being an object related to our bodily sensations. It can express far more than the characteristics of an image; it can express human spiritual perception—for example, cold and warmth, expansion and contraction, roughness, or smoothness and roundness, or ruggedness. How to express the tension a person feels in society, the real responses of the human spirit in certain concrete environments, and an imaginative image combining multiple factors.

First, look at William Blake’s painting The Ghost of a Flea. He believed that all souls have human form, only their appearances differ from those of humans—for example, these flea souls have sharp teeth, bald heads, relatively strong bones, sharp claws, and long pointed tongues protruding outward. This is because he believed that only extremely greedy and bloodthirsty souls would be reincarnated into the body of a flea. In the painting, the figure has both hands and feet spread out, eyes fixed on a bowl full of blood in his hands, ready to eat at any moment, and his spirit is in a state of excitation. William Blake expresses human greed through the form of the human body. I can clearly feel that the body of this flea soul is filled with desire; every cell, muscle, and drop of blood is trembling and swelling. Such an image does not follow a certain tendency, but expresses a most fundamental human feeling, a human imagination of humanity itself. What would greed look like if it had a shape? Or what does this part of greed in the human soul look like? Similarly, we can look at Michelangelo’s Prisoner sculptures. That group of sculptures is his unfinished work, and from this we can strip away some of the background stories and character identities attached to these human-body sculptures, and focus on looking at the human body itself. In these sculptures, the heads and feet are trapped within the marble, or rather the marble has not yet been carved out; most of the heads are lowered, and the arms are raised upward to support the stone above, as if holding up a rock, as if trying to break free from this prison. Within their bodies there is a wild, surging passion that seems about to break out, yet they are firmly trapped by an original, hard, heavy force—the uncarved marble. But from the muscles he constructed and the interesting gestures, we can feel a tenacity of life, a longing for freedom, and a resistance to oppression. I think this is precisely the meaning of studying anatomy: not in order to paint someone who looks like a certain person in reality, but in order to find an image with which one’s own body can empathize, an image capable of expressing force and expressing a construction of the human spirit.
“How do you know but ev’ry Bird that cuts the airy way, Is an immense world of delight, clos’d by your senses five?”
William Blake
If we call William Blake’s body the “imagined body,” we can find this characteristic: the body serves a stable idea; the painter uses vision as a reference and paints the body through a rational understanding of anatomy. In contrast are Merleau-Ponty’s understanding of Cézanne’s body as “body as an organ” and Deleuze’s understanding of Francis Bacon’s body as “body without organs.” “Body as an organ” is the painter-subject affected by the environment; at this moment, if he paints the body according to the phenomena he himself feels, the body in his painting carries this affected organ. Take Cézanne’s Five Bathers as an example: the human body is no longer merely an object to be viewed and represented, but an organ for perceiving and experiencing the world. Through thick brushstrokes, simplified bodily contours, and the interweaving of warm and cold colors, Cézanne weakens traditional body painting’s pursuit of anatomical accuracy and ideal beauty. The figure’s body and the surrounding natural environment merge with each other, as if becoming part of the landscape. The body is both a material existence and a medium for perceiving space, light, and nature. Thus Cézanne transforms the human body from a purely visual object into a carrier connecting bodily experience and the external world.

“Our own body is in the world as the heart is in the organism: it keeps the visible spectacle constantly alive, it breathes life into it and sustains it inwardly, and with it forms a system.”
Phenomenology of Perception, trans. Colin Smith, 1962, p. 235.
Deleuze is not satisfied with the statement that the body is merely an organ. He believes that the body is an object that receives various invisible forces; it is not a stable organization, but is at every moment in various deformations and distortions. In Francis Bacon’s paintings, the body undergoes various degrees of distortion, swelling, contraction, rupture, and even mutual fusion with the background, or intermingling with certain furniture such as sinks and umbrellas. This composite image does not specifically point to a symbolic relationship, but depicts a kind of continuous pressure and various tensions that a person bears in existing in the world.

“The body without organs is opposed less to organs than to that organization of organs we call an organism.”
Gilles Deleuze, Francis Bacon: The Logic of Sensation Chapter 7, Hysteria.
Two different painting methodology
We distinguish two ways of painting. One is that there is a detailed plan in the mind: one has thought out a certain compositional form, tone, and painting theme, what background story it has, what kind of image it is, and then gathers many painting references, determines the positions of all painting objects and the composition, and has in the mind an impression of what a good painting is, and then proceeds to paint. This is a completely rational-subject way of painting. There is another way of painting: there is an inspiration in the mind, an impulse to express, but it is chaotic; there may not necessarily be an object, not necessarily a concrete image, and one does not know what tone should be used, nor where the line should be placed, but instead lets the line move by itself. And the traces on the canvas give her a premonition of the next trace; gradually an image emerges. This image is beyond the painter’s expectations, because it only becomes clear after the painting is finished, rather than being clear from the beginning. This is a kind of doodle painting advocated by Jane Bennett. She wants to use this to prove that in an action the human is not the only factor, and that the establishment of the subject can occur in the process. In her book Influx and Efflux, Jane Bennett mentions that in an action it is not only the decisions in which the subject participates that play a role; those nonhuman existences—such as material air, sunlight, and the objects of action—all participate in this action and affect the subject. The affected subject then further affects the subsequent events.
Let us suppose a scenario: the doodler releases control and lets bodily sensations drive the movement of lines; suddenly she is surprised to discover a shape, and this shape in turn affects the doodler’s bodily sensations, and then the previous steps are repeated.

Compared with this, Marion Milner’s method is more psychologically oriented. When the painter reaches a certain point, he discovers a certain feature; this feature evokes a certain memory and stirs a certain desire in him. He then draws the remaining features of the image according to this feeling, and finally the image in turn affects the painter. Perhaps a certain image appears cyclically again and again, and this can help him think about his own psychological patterns, analyze his unconscious, and analyze his way of living with trauma. In this kind of transformative painting, the painter does not beforehand endow the image with any background story or any identity, but after the image emerges, it itself becomes a feature—a composite, hybrid intermediary that originates from experience and instinct yet exceeds the subject’s framework of understanding, or enables the subject to analyze his own psychology.

“a dialogue relationship between thought and the bit of the external world represented by the marks made on the paper”
Marion Milner, On Not Being Able to Paint, 2010 edition, p. 136
My method of drawing and painting
I have adopted this kind of automatic painting to paint the painter’s own image. This image simultaneously fuses multiple forms: it is an imagined mask of identity (an autonomous identity), an I merged with entities (a flowing process-machine), an I responding to the Big Other (the zeitgeist, a certain flattering aesthetic or metaphysical state), and also a split reflection of the subject (an abstract inconsistency, a multiple body). In other words, it is a multi-hybrid chimera, and also part of a constantly flowing and changing metamorphosing subject.
The traditional naturalistic self-portrait implicitly contains an epistemological assumption: the painter is a relatively stable subject, and the painting is this subject’s representation of itself. But automatic painting breaks this relationship. It makes the painter lose complete control over the generation of the image, and also prevents the painter from determining in advance the self-image that will finally appear. Thus: the painter is both creator and created object; the painter is both viewer and viewed; the painter is both subject and a component in the production process of the painting machine; the self-portrait is both the expression of identity and the generation of identity.


This painting began with an idea: a teacher wants the student to be obedient and to adopt the teacher’s own perspective, going to great lengths to replace the student’s vision with their own. As a result, the student becomes trapped, and can see even less clearly. The drawing was made relatively early, and I had not yet introduced environmental factors and invisible forces into it, so the meaning shifted significantly during the painting stage. The figures remained a teacher and a student, but I brought in a great deal of my own memory: the warm light at home when I returned as a child, the wooden door, the reflection on the tiled floor, the stubborn, powerful, and angry figure of my mother, who was also my teacher, the chaotic and heavy pressure she placed on me, and my own unease. As I painted, feelings of resentment and frustration surged into the work, and in the end it came to resemble two people locked in a struggle. Perhaps there is an eternal adversary within me; it drives me to fight, and has also become part of who I am.
One especially important point about drawing and painting is that in the process of drawing and painting, all those things that seem unrelated—for example, a human hand and a branch, an eye and a flame—can be combined, deformed, and fused into an overall image available for people to view. An unspeakable complexity is concisely woven into a viewable entity. Only when we have completed this piece and see it again can we rediscover the meaning of it, and even rediscover a meaning that we had not previously recognized, and thereby come to know ourselves anew. Even more, by adding Daoist discourse, we can ask: why must we know a determinate self? Why should self-knowledge be taken as the destination, rather than acknowledging this fluidity and changeability, and understanding Dao as an immanent processual order in which subjectivity is continuously generated, transformed, and reorganized within relations?
Images




References
Jane Bennett: Partaker of influx and effluxs (2025)|https://gagosian.com/quarterly/2025/03/06/interview-jane-bennett-partaker-of-influx-and-efflux/
Jane Bennett, influx and efflux: Writing Up with Walt Whitman(2020),Duke University Press Durham and London 2020, ISBN 9781478008309
Jane Bennett, Out for a Walk| Open Access (CC BY-NC-SA 3.0.) | Felix Meiner Verlag, 2019 | DOI: 10.28937/ZMK-10-1
Donna Haraway, “A Cyborg Manifesto: Science, Technology, and Socialist-Feminism in the Late Twentieth Century,” in Simians, Cyborgs and Women: The Reinvention of Nature (New York; Routledge, 1991), pp.149-181.
Gille Delueze, Francis Bacon: the logic of sensation Translated from the French by Daniel W. Smith continuum LONDON • NEW YORK,2003, ISBN 0-8264-6647-8
Zhuangzi, Zhuangzi ,Translated by Yong Fang, Zhonghua Book Company Press 2015,ISBN 978-7-101-10952-8
Marion Milner, On not being able to paint, published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2010,ISBN 0-203-83365-1
Bethan Stevens, THE BRITISH MUSEUM William Blake, the British Museum press, 2005, ISBN-13: 978-0-7141-2645-6
About the author
Yicheng cai (MA Fine Art Drawing) is an artist based in Wuxi working with drawing and painting. He graduated in 2027. Follow his work at https://xhslink.cn/o/8tlYrD1Y4GH Text as link.