I don’t know if the internet really used to be better. I suspect it probably wasn’t. There were fewer people online, technology was slower, websites were harder to navigate, and a lot of the things I remember fondly probably had their own problems that I was too young to notice. Yet when I think about the internet I grew up with, I remember it as being brighter somehow. More colourful, more playful, and more human.
Maybe this is just nostalgia. Maybe the sky was never really more blue. But I think there is something behind that feeling. The internet has changed, and so has the way we use it. What was once imagined as a space for creativity, participation and possibility has increasingly become an enormous infrastructure built around data, attention and profit. We have gained convenience, speed and access, but I wonder if we have lost some of the joy of simply being there.
web 2.0
The early internet was somewhat difficult to navigate compared to what we have now. I even remember my mother reminiscing about older computers and how long she would have to wait for them to boot up. Its much easier to navigate now. Everything is curated, optimised and predicted. Search engines now give a good guess of what you intended to search, social media provides an algorithm just for you. No time to waste. But there was a joy in navigating what felt like the wild west of the internet.
Browsing was an art in itself. Getting lost in one website could lead to another, and another, until you had somehow ended up somewhere you never intended to go. I think this is part of what I remember when I think about the early internet. It was not necessarily better looking or easier to use. In fact, a lot of it was ugly, clunky and frustrating – even watching a YouTube video could be a challenge when it was flooded with all those Annotations.
But it was often visibly personal. MySpace profiles could be covered in music, photographs, glitter, colours and custom layouts. Personal websites and blogs could feel like someone’s bedroom, with their interests and personality scattered everywhere. There was a sense that the person using the internet could actually leave a mark on it.
This was part of a wider change in how the internet was understood. The emergence of Web 2.0 brought an emphasis on participation and user-generated content. Rather than simply receiving information, users could create, share and reshape it. Social platforms, blogs, forums and online communities gave ordinary people new ways of expressing themselves and building identities online (OECD, 2007).
For artists, this opened up another possibility. The internet was not simply somewhere to display existing work; it could become the material that the work was made from. Net art emerged alongside the early web, with artists experimenting with websites, hyperlinks, browsers and the possibilities of a medium that was still being invented. The internet could be a gallery, a canvas, a community, or simply the artwork itself.
frictionless web
At some point, this experience seemed to shift. There was no exact moment when the playful internet disappeared and the corporate internet arrived. The companies were always there, and the early internet was never as innocent as nostalgia makes it seem. But as more people came online, more money entered the industry, and more of our lives became connected to digital platforms, the information we produced simply by existing online became increasingly valuable.
Google is an interesting symbol of this change. Its early corporate culture became associated with the phrase “Don’t be evil”, an unofficial motto that expressed an idea that a technology company should have responsibilities beyond simply making money. The phrase was eventually reduced and removed from most of Google’s code of conduct as the company became part of Alphabet (Basu, 2015).
As technology became more embedded in everyday life, our participation became valuable in a different way. We were not only users anymore. We were also sources of information. Our searches, clicks, locations, friendships, preferences and habits could all become data. This data could be analysed to predict behaviour and, increasingly, to influence and monetise it. Shoshana Zuboff describes this economic model as “surveillance capitalism”: the transformation of human experience into behavioural data that can be used to generate predictions and profit.
The Cambridge Analytica scandal made this uncomfortable idea much more tangible. In 2018, it became public that data relating to millions of Facebook users had been harvested and used for political profiling and targeting (FTC, 2019). Information that people had given to a social platform could be turned into something much bigger than just a space to share, now seemingly without people’s explicit awareness. The corners and rooms of the internet people built to be discovered and taken refuge in suddenly seemed to listen and watch.
We had always been told that we were using these platforms for free. But increasingly, it became difficult to ignore what was being exchanged. The internet was not free. The price was our attention, our personal information, or our behaviour.
This has changed how the internet feels.
The things that once seemed exciting about technology, such as being connected to everyone, always having access to information, having a platform to express yourself, can now feel overwhelming. Social media is designed to keep us engaged. Notifications follow us. Algorithms learn what makes us angry, curious or afraid. There is always another post, another video, another person to compare ourselves to. Our attention isn’t the only thing consumed by this network. We talk about “the cloud” as if our information floats somewhere weightless above us, but the internet depends on enormous amounts of physical infrastructure, growing endlessly to keep up with the demands of data processing. Data centres scream away in the dead of night, consuming, polluting, a reminder of the price of instant information.
Suddenly, Dead Internet Theory sound less silly than it did at first. Now, more than half of global web traffic can be attributed to bot activity, with human activity making up only 42.6% of requests (Elkins, 2026). The theory expresses a fear that the internet is becoming repetitive, automated and strangely empty; that the people we thought were on the other side of the screen are increasingly difficult to distinguish from algorithms, advertising and generated content.
to take up space
It would be easy to end this essay by saying that the old internet was better and that everything has gone downhill since. I don’t think that is true, and I don’t think it would be particularly useful. We cannot go back to the internet of the early 2000s. We probably shouldn’t. Technology has made incredible things possible, and the internet has allowed people to communicate, create communities and access information on a scale that would have been unimaginable before it existed.
What interests me more is whether we can bring back some of the playfulness that seems to have been lost in a pool of bots and anxiety. Instead of an optimised, passive approach to consuming information technology, how can we participate in it again?
The art is not lost. I see this in things like cyberdecks and custom technology. A cyberdeck can be an intentionally strange, personal computer, often built or modified by the person using it. It is almost the opposite of the modern consumer technology experience. Instead of settling for what a company has decided a computer should look like, you can decide what your computer should be. You can build something inefficient, impractical, or maybe just right for you. There is something important about that.
The same thing can be seen in contemporary net art, creative coding, DIY electronics, personal websites and the many small online communities that exist outside the biggest platforms. They might not have millions of users, generate revenue, or have a direct function, but maybe that is the point.
There is value in making something because you want to make it, to take up space, to say ‘I’m here too’. There is value in a website that only a few people visit. There is value in a strange handmade computer that does something a normal laptop could already do. There is value in an online community that isn’t battling to become the next social network.
These things remind me of what I think I miss about the early internet. Not necessarily its technology, but its sense of possibility. The internet was once something that people made visible pieces of themselves inside. Perhaps we can do that again.
As artists, this feels particularly important. So much of contemporary technology is designed to remove friction. It predicts what we want, gives us templates, automates processes and increasingly generates content for us. These tools can be useful, but there is also something to be said for making things badly, slowly, unnecessarily and with other people. Creativity is one of the things that cannot be completely optimised. People will always want to decorate their little corner of the world. They will always want to make things that are strange, personal and difficult to explain. They will always find each other.
Maybe that is how we make the internet feel human again.
maybe the sky was never bluer
I started this essay with a memory of the internet being brighter, and I still don’t know whether that memory is true.
Maybe I remember the sky being more blue because I was younger. Maybe I remember technology differently because I was discovering it rather than living inside it. Maybe the early internet was never as colourful or innocent as I imagine it.
But I don’t think that makes the feeling meaningless. The internet has changed. We have gone from making personal spaces to inhabiting enormous platforms. We have gone from getting lost in strange corners of the web to being guided towards whatever an algorithm thinks we should see. We have gained convenience and connection, but we have also become aware of the systems watching, measuring and profiting from us.
Perhaps what I miss is not the old internet itself, but the idea that technology could belong to us. That is what I see in people building cyberdecks, making net art, creating personal websites, starting small communities and finding new ways to play with technology. They are not trying to recreate the past exactly. They are making new possibilities.
Maybe we cannot return to the internet we remember. Maybe the sky really was never more blue. But we are still creative. We still make communities. We still have the ability to take the technology around us and make something that wasn’t there before. And that is enough to make the sky a little more blue ourselves.
Images
O’Rear, C. and Microsoft (1996). Bliss. [Photograph].
References
Basu, T. (2015). New Google parent company drops ‘don’t be evil’ motto. [online] Time. Available at: https://time.com/4060575/alphabet-google-dont-be-evil/.
Elkins, S. (2026). Bot web traffic has overtaken human web traffic, data shows. [online] NBC News. Available at: https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/tech-news/bot-web-traffic-overtaken-human-web-traffic-data-shows-rcna348522.
FTC (2019). FTC sues Cambridge Analytica, settles with former CEO and app developer. [online] Federal Trade Commission. Available at: https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2019/07/ftc-sues-cambridge-analytica-settles-former-ceo-app-developer.
OECD (2007). Participative web and user-created content. [online] OECD. Available at: https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/participative-web-and-user-created-content_9789264037472-en.html.
Zuboff, S. (2019). The age of surveillance capitalism: The fight for a human future at the new frontier of power. New York: Public Affairs.
About the author
Nastasija Milosev (also known as Naja) is a computational artist based in London, exploring the emotional and psychological experience of living alongside and within digital technologies. Her work responds to this relationship between humans and technology, investigating how online identity and digitally mediated experiences might be made physical, spatial and embodied.