Categories
Issue 5: Dispersion

The Order of Chaos

This essay explores how belief can break down existing perceptions of reality and create new forms of understanding. Inspired by my fieldwork on Nuo Tang Theatre in Guizhou, I use painting to express chaos, mystery and the continuous cycle of destruction and reconstruction.

Nuo masks photographed during fieldwork in Guizhou, China, 2026. Photograph by the author.

Introduction: When the Familiar World No Longer Holds

I have always been strongly drawn to things that are mysterious, irrational and difficult to explain in words. I am especially interested in the deities, rituals and symbolic images of folk belief. They seem to give visible form to things that would otherwise remain unseen or impossible to understand.

I often wonder how much of what we call reality comes from direct experience, and how much is shaped by the education, culture and habits of thought we grow up with. We are used to explaining the world through reason and believing that it follows a stable order. But what happens when we encounter something that our existing knowledge cannot explain? Could that order suddenly collapse?

I became interested in how belief might change the way a person understands the world. Belief does not always bring comfort or peace. It may also challenge an existing worldview, leading someone through doubt, confusion and a loss of control before they begin to build a new way of understanding reality.

Yet I do not see this new order as an endpoint. As we encounter unfamiliar things, the ideas we have built may be challenged again. For me, belief and perception form a cycle: an old order breaks down, a new one emerges from its ruins, and that new order may eventually collapse in the face of another unknown experience. This continuing process is what I want to explore through painting.

Encountering the Unknown: Fieldwork in Guizhou

Before travelling to Guizhou, most of what I knew about Nuo Tang Theatre came from books, photographs and online videos. I was initially attracted to its striking imagery: expressive masks, deities, ritual gestures and symbolic objects. I found them mysterious and wanted to understand them more deeply.

I travelled to Dejiang, Guizhou, to carry out fieldwork. With the help of the local culture and tourism authorities, I contacted An Yongbai, a practitioner and inheritor of Nuo Tang Theatre. I also visited a traditional mask maker’s workshop, where I observed the making process and spoke with practitioners about the history and current situation of the tradition.

What affected me most, however, was seeing a complete ritual performance in person for the first time.

When the gongs began and the performers started moving, I suddenly felt an atmosphere that was difficult to describe. Masks, sound, bodily movement and the surrounding space came together to form what felt like a world entirely different from everyday life. I experienced a mixture of mystery, awe, curiosity and excitement. For a moment, I almost forgot that I had come as an observer. I felt surrounded by the event, as though I had entered another world.

Watching a video had allowed me to see the form of the ritual, but it could not communicate the combined impact of sound, space and physical presence.

Nuo Tang Theatre ritual performance in Dejiang, Guizhou, China, 2026. Photograph by the author.

In The Idea of the Holy, Rudolf Otto describes an experience of the sacred that cannot be fully explained through rational concepts, and which may involve both awe and fear as well as attraction (Otto, 1923). His ideas helped me think about my response at the ritual. I was not simply frightened by its unfamiliarity; I became more curious. I wanted to understand why the masks carried particular meanings and how the sounds and movements could produce such powerful feelings.

Of course, attending one ritual did not mean that I fully understood the beliefs of local practitioners. For them, the ritual may be part of familiar cultural and social life. My sense of mystery came partly from my own position as a visitor. Even so, that unfamiliarity made me realise how strongly our understanding of the world depends on our experiences.

 How Belief Can Disrupt an Existing Order

In everyday life, we tend to give things fixed meanings. A mask is an object, a sound is something we hear, and a performance is something we watch. Yet during the Nuo ritual, these things seemed to become more than their outward forms.

Mircea Eliade discusses how the sacred can give everyday objects and spaces meanings that differ from those of ordinary life (Eliade, 1959). Within a system of belief, a familiar place may become sacred, and a physical object may carry significance beyond its material form.

This made me reconsider the masks I had seen. As a painter, I first noticed their shapes, colours and expressions. But within the ritual they were connected to belief, action and cultural memory. The same object can mean very different things within different ways of understanding the world.

I began to realise that reality is not only what we see. It also depends on how we interpret what we see. When someone comes to believe in a different explanation of the world, events once understood as coincidences might become signs, and ordinary objects might acquire sacred meanings. The physical world has not necessarily changed, but the person’s inner world may have changed completely.

This possibility fascinates me because it suggests that what we regard as a stable order may be more fragile than we think. Still, I do not believe that faith necessarily creates chaos. For people who have lived within a belief system for a long time, it may provide stability. What interests me is the uncertain moment of moving from one way of understanding reality into another.

Chaos and Disorder: Between Two Worlds

I am interested less in the final form of someone’s belief than in the process through which an old understanding stops working and a new one has not yet taken shape. It is a contradictory condition: what once seemed reliable no longer explains experience, but a new explanation is not yet convincing. It can feel as though a person is standing between two worlds.

Victor Turner discusses liminality in The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-Structure (Turner, 1969). In certain rites of passage, people temporarily leave behind their previous identities and social positions before entering a new state. Although Turner is writing about social rituals rather than every form of psychological uncertainty, the idea of being between states helps me think about changes in perception.

I began to ask whether chaos must always be negative. Perhaps when familiar rules stop working, things that once seemed impossible can become imaginable. Our ideas and images are no longer held within the limits of everyday logic.

This has increasingly influenced my painting. I do not want simply to reproduce the visible world or make every form obey a realistic spatial order. I want viewers to experience some disorder, so that they cannot immediately explain everything through familiar habits of looking.

I try to bring figurative and abstract forms together, allowing recognisable shapes to exist alongside images that resist easy interpretation. Something may look familiar at first, but its relationship to the rest of the painting may not follow the logic of ordinary reality. I hope this tension creates a feeling of being somewhere between the known and the unknown.

For me, chaos is not simply a mistake to be corrected. It may be the beginning of creation. Losing certainty can also give us the freedom to imagine the world differently.

The Cthulhu Mythos: The Psychological Shock of the Unknown

When I think about the collapse of certainty, I often return to H. P. Lovecraft’s Cthulhu Mythos. What attracts me is not only the strange, enormous and almost indescribable beings in his stories, but also the psychological shock experienced by people who encounter them.

In Lovecraft’s cosmic horror, human beings often believe that knowledge and reason will allow them to understand the world. When they discover beings or realities beyond human comprehension, that confidence begins to break down. The deepest fear is not simply the appearance of a monster. It is the possibility that the reality we have always trusted is only a tiny part of something far larger and stranger.

In Supernatural Horror in Literature, Lovecraft discusses the power of the unknown and the atmosphere of the inexplicable in supernatural horror (Lovecraft, 1927). This connects with my interest in belief. When someone encounters something that cannot be understood through existing knowledge, their way of thinking may be shaken before anything changes in the physical world.

I do not mean that the Cthulhu Mythos and lived religious beliefs are the same. Lovecraft’s stories often emphasise human insignificance and helplessness, while religious practices may offer comfort, belonging and order. What interests me is a shared question: what happens to our sense of reality when we meet something beyond our understanding?

I am especially drawn to the relationship between fear and attraction. Some things unsettle us, yet we still want to know more about them. We want to understand the unknown, while fearing that understanding it may change everything we believe.

This is the feeling I want to explore in my paintings. I do not simply want to make frightening images. I want a painting to feel like a world that cannot be fully explained: viewers might recognise certain forms, but remain unsure how they belong together.

I hope that uncertainty encourages viewers to become curious, and to imagine that another world might exist beyond what they can see.

Building Another World from the Ruins: My Painting Practice

My fieldwork in Guizhou helped me understand that what draws me to traditional culture is not only its visual symbolism, but also the ways belief can change how people understand the world.

At the Nuo ritual, I felt an atmosphere unlike ordinary life. It awakened personal feelings and images in my mind, and made me wonder whether painting could create a world that similarly unsettles familiar ways of seeing.

I do not want simply to copy masks, figures or ritual scenes onto canvas. What matters more to me is the experience they brought about in me. I want to communicate something of that mystery, excitement and difficulty of explanation.

This is why I have begun trying to disrupt conventional visual order. The relationships between forms do not always need to be logical, and space does not always have to follow realistic rules. Figurative elements can offer a sense of recognition, while abstract passages interrupt it. I want viewers to feel that they almost understand what they are looking at, but cannot turn everything into one clear story.

Stuart Hall argues that representation does not simply copy reality; it participates in the production of meaning (Hall, 1997). For me, painting is not only a record of an existing world. By changing forms, spaces and relationships, I can create another way of seeing. This imagined world is still rooted in my own experience, but that experience is reorganised on the canvas.

My painting, 2026. Photograph by the author.

My painting, 2026. Photograph by the author.

I have also realised that this movement between chaos and order happens during the act of painting itself. Sometimes I begin without a complete plan, only a vague feeling or image. As the painting develops, new forms, colours and relationships appear and change my original intention.

Some passages are built up and then covered or disrupted by new marks. A composition that once seemed balanced can suddenly stop working, and I have to find a new relationship between its parts. I do not always know what the final image will look like when I begin. Often, I discover it through painting.

Detail of my painting, 2026. Photograph by the author.

This process reminds me of the relationship between belief and perception. We establish an order to make sense of the world. Then a new experience challenges it, and we have to rethink and rebuild. In painting, I construct a world, disturb its structure and allow new relationships to emerge from the disorder.

But I do not want the new order to become too complete. I want to leave contradictions, uneasy relationships and things that cannot be explained. Mystery, for me, is not a puzzle that must eventually be solved. It is something that keeps my curiosity alive.

If everything could be explained and every question answered, perhaps the world would become less compelling to me. I want my paintings to preserve the unknown and allow viewers to search for their own understanding somewhere between familiarity and strangeness, order and chaos.

An Order That Is Never Complete

This fieldwork has changed the way I think about belief. I was first drawn to the mysterious imagery of traditional practices. After being present at a Nuo ritual, I became more interested in how belief can change the way a person understands reality.

I no longer see the relationship between belief and perception as a simple journey from chaos to order. Belief may give someone a structure through which to understand the world, but it may also challenge what they previously accepted as true. When an old way of thinking no longer works, new meanings may emerge from the confusion. Yet those meanings are not necessarily final. We may still encounter things that we cannot explain, and question what we once believed.

In my painting, I want to create a mysterious world that does not follow the rules of everyday life. It does not have to be entirely logical or provide a clear answer. I hope viewers can put aside their usual expectations for a moment and enter something unfamiliar but compelling.

For me, art is not about proving that a belief is true, or fully explaining the world. It can be a response to the unknown. I want my work to unsettle established certainties and look for new possibilities within disorder. Perhaps what fascinates me most is not the order we eventually build, but the process through which a world falls apart and takes shape again.

Images

1.Nuo masks photographed during fieldwork in Guizhou, China, 2026. Photograph by the author.

2.Nuo Tang Theatre ritual performance in Dejiang, Guizhou, China, 2026. Photograph by the author.

3.My painting, 2026. Photograph by the author.

4. Detail of my painting, 2026. Photograph by the author.

References

Eliade, M. (1959) The Sacred and the Profane: The Nature of Religion. Translated by W.R. Trask. New York: Harcourt, Brace & World.

Hall, S. (ed.) (1997) Representation: Cultural Representations and Signifying Practices. London: SAGE Publications in association with The Open University.

Lovecraft, H.P. (1927) ‘Supernatural Horror in Literature’. The Recluse, 1, pp. 23–59.

Otto, R. (1923) The Idea of the Holy. Translated by J.W. Harvey. London: Oxford University Press.

Turner, V. (1969) The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-Structure. Chicago: Aldine Publishing Company.

About the author

Yuan Gao is a Chinese artist currently based in London, studying MA Fine Art: Painting at Camberwell College of Arts, University of the Arts London (2025–2026). Her practice explores traditional Chinese culture, folklore, mysticism and belief. Working primarily with painting, she combines abstract and figurative elements to explore the relationship between personal experience, ritual and the unknown. Her recent research focuses on Nuo Tang Theatre in Guizhou, China, and how spiritual experiences can reshape our perception of reality.

Instagram:yuan011021